Posts

Showing posts with the label R. v. Jordan

Post-Verdict Delay Gets its Own Ceiling: R. v. Jordan

In many criminal cases, particularly the more serious cases, sentencing will, of necessity, take time, sometimes a matter of months. D angerous offender applications, situations in which expert reports are required or extensive evidence is tendered, for instance,  significantly lengthen the sentencing process.   While the Jordan analysis does apply to post-verdict delay, the presumptive ceilings established in Jordan do not include post-verdict delay. Post-verdict delay, for the purposes of applying a presumptive ceiling, is to be assessed separately from pre-verdict delay and is subject to its own presumptive ceiling.                 R. v. Charley , 2019 ONCA 726. The Court of Appeal for Ontario in R. v. Charley  fixed that ceiling at five months. Five months is the point at which the delay is sufficiently long that it is regarded as presumptively unreasonable for the purposes of s. 11(b). The onus falls to...

Applying R. v. Jordan: Superior Court but no Preliminary Inquiry

In Jordan , the Supreme Court   created a new analytic framework for determining whether a breach of section 11 ( b ) of the Charter had occurred.  At its centre is “a ceiling beyond which delay is presumptively unreasonable.” The Court set two presumptive ceilings for the period of time from the date an accused person is charged to the actual, or anticipated, end of trial (the total delay): 18 months for cases going to trial in the provincial court, and 30 months for cases going to trial in the superior court (or cases going to trial in the provincial court after a preliminary inquiry). R v Jordan , 2016 SCC 27 (CanLII) at para 46. R. v. Jordan does not distinguish between a one-step trial process (without preliminary inquiry) and a two-step trial process (with preliminary inquiry) in the Superior Court. R v Schenkels , 2017 MBCA 62 (CanLII); R v Cabrera , 2016 ABQB 707 (CanLII) , leave to appeal to Alta CA pending. It does, however, recognize an ex...