Section 8: Good Searches Gone Bad
The
validity of the search warrant does not end the inquiry as to the admissibility
of the evidence when a Charter
infringement occurred during the investigatory process that led to the search
and seizure at issue.
A
s. 24(2) Charter analysis is
triggered when an infringement of s. 8 has occurred in the investigatory
process, apart from a subsequent reasonable search pursuant to a valid warrant.
R. v. Strachan,
1988 CanLII 25 (SCC);
R. v. Grant, [1993] 3 S.C.R. 223, at p. 254;
see also R. v. Strauss, 2017 ONCA 628, at para. 45.
As
the Supreme Court said in Grant
(1993), at p. 255:
The warrantless
searches, while perhaps not causally linked to the evidence tendered, were
nevertheless an integral component in a series of investigative tactics which
led to the unearthing of the evidence in question … to find otherwise would be
to ignore the possible tainting effect which a Charter violation might have on the otherwise
legitimate components of searches by state authorities.
See also, R. v. Strachan, 1988 CanLII 25 (SCC), at para. 39, 40, 47.
Stuart O’Connell, O’Connell
Law Group, www.leadersinlaw.ca
Comments
Post a Comment