Police may Be Exempt From Speed Limits But Not From Criminal Offences Involving Speed
Section 128(13) of the Highway Traffic Act provides that
speed limits do not apply to police department vehicles used in the lawful
performance of a police officer’s duties. If an officer is in the lawful
performance of their police duties, this provision exempts police officers from
speed limits, but not from criminal offences such as dangerous driving [FN].
R. v. Romano, 2017 ONCA 837, at para. 89.
Highway Traffic Act, RSO
1990, c H.8.
Fire department vehicles
and police vehicles
128(13) The speed limits
prescribed under this section or any regulation or by-law passed under this
section do not apply to,(a) a fire department
vehicle while proceeding to a fire or responding to, but not returning from, a
fire alarm or other emergency call;(b) a police department
vehicle being used in the lawful performance of a police officer’s duties; or (c) an ambulance while
responding to an emergency call or being used to transport a patient or injured
person in an emergency situation.
[FN] To establish the mens rea of dangerous
driving the Crown must prove that the manner of driving “was a marked departure from the standard
of care that a reasonable person would observe in the accused’s circumstances”. In
applying this “modified objective test” in which the “accused’s circumstances”
are relevant, the status of the accused as an on-duty police officer acting in
the course of his duties must be considered (Romano, at para. 87). The question becomes: was the manner of the officer’s driving a marked
departure from the standard of care that a reasonable on-duty police office
would observe in the circumstances. Obviously, driving
at an excessive rate of speed may be a relevant consideration within that
standard of care analysis.
Stuart
O’Connell, O’Connell Law Group, www.leadersinlaw.ca
Comments
Post a Comment