Pleading Guilty Without Knowing that you may be Deported
To
be valid, a guilty plea must be voluntary and unequivocal. It must also be
informed, in the sense that the accused must be aware of the allegations made against
him, and of the effect and “legally relevant collateral consequences” of that
plea.
See R. v. Pineda, 2019 ONCA 935, where the Court of Appeal for Ontario found that the appellant had not been informed by his counsel and was not otherwise aware of the potentially serious immigration consequences arising from his guilty pleas, specifically that he could be deported without a right of appeal. Guilty pleas and consequent convictions set aside. New trial ordered.
R.
v. Wong, 2018 SCC 25, [2018] 1 S.C.R. 696, at paras. 3-4.
Legally
relevant collateral consequences include immigration consequences.
To
set aside a presumptively valid plea, the appellant must establish that:
(i)
he
was unaware of a legally relevant consequence of the plea, assessed
objectively; and
(ii)
he
has suffered prejudice, in the sense that he would have acted differently had
he been properly made aware of the consequences.
Wong, 2018 SCC 25,
[2018] 1 S.C.R. 696, at para. 33.
Where
deportation is within the range of possible consequences, and where the accused
would not otherwise have obtained that information (for instance, by consulting
with an immigration lawyer), defence counsel
should go further than simply informing the client that serious immigration
consequences might follow from the guilty plea.
Counsel should specifically inform the client as to the prospect of
deportation.
See R. v. Pineda, 2019 ONCA 935, where the Court of Appeal for Ontario found that the appellant had not been informed by his counsel and was not otherwise aware of the potentially serious immigration consequences arising from his guilty pleas, specifically that he could be deported without a right of appeal. Guilty pleas and consequent convictions set aside. New trial ordered.
Stuart O’Connell, O’Connell Law Group, Toronto.
Tel: 416-628-1942
Comments
Post a Comment