The Right to Effective Assistance of Counsel
Today the right to effective
assistance of counsel extends to all accused persons. In Canada that
right is seen as a principle of fundamental justice. It is derived from
the evolution of the common law, s.650(3) of the Criminal Code of Canada and
sections 7 and 11(d) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Where counsel fails to provide
effective representation, the fairness of the trial, measured both by reference
to the reliability of the verdict and the adjudicative fairness of the process
used to arrive at the verdict, suffers. In some cases the result will be
a miscarriage of justice.
To succeed in setting aside a
trial verdict on the basis of the ineffective assistance of counsel, the
appellant must show two things:
1. That
counsel’s acts or omissions constituted incompetence
Incompetence is
determined by a reasonableness standard. The analysis proceeds upon a
strong presumption that counsel’s conduct fell within the wide range of
reasonable professional assistance. The onus is on the appellant to
establish the acts or omissions of counsel that are alleged not to have been
the result of reasonable professional judgment. The wisdom of hindsight
has no place in this assessment.
R. v. G.D.B., 2000 SCC 22 (CanLII) at
para 27
Where, in the
course of a trial, counsel makes a decision in good faith and in the best
interests of his client, a court should not look behind it save only to prevent
a miscarriage of justice:
Supra, at para 34
2. That
a miscarriage of justice resulted
Miscarriages of justice
may take many forms in this context. In some instances, counsel’s
performance may have resulted in procedural unfairness. In others, the
reliability of the trial’s result may have been compromised. In those cases
where it is apparent that no prejudice has occurred, it will usually be
undesirable for appellate courts to consider the performance component of the
analysis. This can be left to the legal profession’s self-governing body.
Supra,
at para 28
Comments
Post a Comment