Guilty Plea but No Election
An accused charged with an indictable offence is entitled
to elect her mode of trial under s. 536(2) of the Criminal Code if the offence is not
a.
an
offence
listed or described in s. 469 – offences falling within the exclusive trial
jurisdiction of the Superior Court of Justice, or
b. an offence listed or described in s. 553 of
the Criminal Code – offences falling
within the absolute jurisdiction of a judge of the Ontario Court of Justice sitting
as a provincial court judge.
It is well settled that the failure to comply with the
election requirements in s. 536(2) (eg. putting the accused to her election as
to the mode of trial) goes to the jurisdiction of the trial court.
The jurisdiction of a judge of the Ontario Court of Justice
to try the accused or to receive and act upon her plea of guilty, depends
entirely upon her choice of that court as her mode of trial.
Absent an election under s.536(2), the provincial court judge
has no jurisdiction to receive and to act upon the plea of guilty that the accused
entered.
R. v.
Tadesse, 2017 ONCA 682, at para. 5 [guilty plea and conviction set
aside and a new trial ordered].
Stuart O’Connell, O’Connell
Law Group, www.leadersinlaw.ca
Comments
Post a Comment