Searches Incident to Detention Conducted for Safety Reasons
Unlike
an arrest, a lawful detention does not automatically give rise to a right to
conduct a search. Police officers can conduct a search for officer
safety, incidental to an investigative detention where the officer believes on
reasonable grounds that his or her safety, or the safety of others is at
risk. As enunciated in cases such as Mann, Clayton and
elsewhere, a vague or non-existent concern for safety is not a basis for a
search.
The Absence
of Handcuffs Does Not Provide a Sufficient Basis to Search
The
mere fact that the accused is not handcuffed does not provide a sufficient
basis to conduct a search incident to detention for safety reasons. If it did,
virtually every detained individual could be searched. There needs to be
more.
R. v.
Arsenault, 2017
ONCJ 19
The Practice of Routinely Conducting Searches Incident
to Detention can Undermine an Officer’s Stated Justification for Conducting a Particular
Search
The
law does not allow officers to search incident to detention simply as a matter
of practice. Evidence establishing that an officer is involved in such an unjustified
practice may be used to undermine that officer’s contention that the reason for
a particular search incident to detention was for officer safety concerns.
R. v.
Arsenault, 2017
ONCJ 19
Comments
Post a Comment