The W.D. Instruction Required where Credibility is a Crucial Issue
Where credibility is a “crucial issue” at trial, failure on the part of
the trial judge to specifically and adequately instruct the jury on credibility
and the burden of proof may constitute a reversible error. As the Supreme Court
held in R. v.
J.H.S., 2008 SCC 30,
[2008] 2 S.C.R. 152, at para. 8:
A series of decisions over at least the past 20 years
has affirmed and reaffirmed the proposition that where credibility is a central
issue in a jury trial, the judge must explain the relationship between the
assessment of credibility and the Crown’s ultimate burden to prove the guilt of
the accused to the criminal standard. A general instruction on reasonable
doubt without adverting to its relationship to the credibility (or lack of
credibility) of the witnesses leaves open too great a possibility of confusion
or misunderstanding.
Comments
Post a Comment