Inherent Jurisdiction: Did the Police Stage a Break-in at the Accused's Home so that they had a Pretext to Enter it?
As part of its inherent jurisdiction, a Superior
Court has the discretionary authority to permit an individual’s testimony to be
audio recorded for the purpose of facilitating voice analysis of that witness
where doing so is necessary to ensure “justice between the parties and to secure a fair
trial between them”.
R.
v. Dunstan, 2017 ONCA 432, at para. 46, in obiter.
In R. v.
Dunstan, the defence sought an order from a Superior Court judge permitting
the defence to use a high-quality microphone to record the testimony of a particular
police officer. The defence alleged that
the officer had staged a break-in to the accused’s home and placed the
anonymous call to police reporting a break-in in order to gain access to his house illegally. Police
responding to the anonymous call discovered significant amounts of various
drugs and cash. On the evidentiary record, the defence was able to establish an
air of reality to its allegation.
Inherent
Jurisdiction
Inherent jurisdiction is a “reserve or fund of
powers” or a “residual source of powers”, which a superior court may draw upon
as necessary whenever it is just or equitable to do so, and in particular to
ensure the observance of the due process of law, to prevent improper vexation or
oppression, to do justice between the parties and to secure a fair trial
between them.
Endean v. British Columbia,
2016 SCC 42, [2016] 2 S.C.R. 162, at para. 23.
Stuart O'Connell, O'Connell Law Group (leadersinlaw.ca).
Stuart O'Connell, O'Connell Law Group (leadersinlaw.ca).
Comments
Post a Comment