Summary Conviction Appeals: Leave to Appeal to the Court of Appeal
Summary
conviction proceedings
are governed by Part XXVII of the Criminal Code.
In
summary conviction appeal proceedings,
the Superior Court of Justice is
the
primary appellate court, and has broad
appellate jurisdiction.
Access
to the court of appeal from these decisions of the Superior Court is restricted to
questions of law alone and only if leave to appeal is granted (section 839,
Criminal Code).
Leave to appeal pursuant to s. 839 should be
granted sparingly. There is no single litmus test that can identify all cases
in which leave should be granted. There are, however, two key variables:
On the one hand, if the issues have significance to
the administration of justice beyond the particular case, then leave may be
granted even if the merits are not particularly strong, though the grounds must
at least be arguable. On the other hand, where the merits appear very strong,
leave to Appeal may be granted even if the issues have no general importance,
especially if the convictions in issue are serious and the applicant is facing
a significant deprivation of his or her Liberty.
When will
it be appropriate for the court of appeal to grant leave?
1. The significance of the
legal issues raised to the general administration of criminal justice, and
2. The merits of the
proposed grounds of appeal.
R. v R.(R.), 2008
ONCA 497, 90 O.R. [3d] 564. Doherty J.A, at para 37.
Comments
Post a Comment