Police Officer Notes: The Blending of Factual Situations with the Passage of Time
When police
officers undertake tasks that are repetitive (such as the administration of a
roadside test) contemporaneous note-taking is crucial to allow officers to
recall evidence with precision. The repetitive nature of a task lends itself to
a blending of different factual situations with the passage of time.
R. v. Dinh, 2010 ONCJ 540 (CanLII), at para. 35.
R. v. Dinh involved alleged impaired
driving and a breath sample device that malfunctioned or failed due to an
uncooperative driver. The evidence from two officers varied or was
contradictory in relation to device calibration and officer and driver
location. Given that case’s circumstances, contemporaneous note-taking
was deemed crucial.
And on the subject of police notes and credibility—
While officers cannot be held to a standard of perfection
in note-taking, the completeness or accuracy of police notes may have an impact
on the case where the credibility of an officer is an issue.
R.
v. Relleve, 2004 MBQB 155
(CanLII), at para. 22, where the court heard conflicting police
evidence, which raised concerns about the credibility of the Crown witnesses.
Stuart O'Connell, O'Connell Law Group (leadersinlaw.ca)
Comments
Post a Comment