Victim Surcharges: How Many do I have to Pay?
Section 737 of the Criminal
Code requires that an offender who is convicted or discharged shall pay a
surcharge.
The surcharge regime has two
objectives:
(i)
to provide funds for victim services, and
(ii)
to increase offenders’ accountability to
victims and the community.
See
R. v. Cloud, 2016 QCCA 567, 340 C.C.C. (3d) 547;
R. v. Tinker, 2017 ONCA 552, at
paras. 86-96.
The surcharge is a unique
penalty in the nature of a general kind of restitution.
R. v.
Crowell (1992), 115 N.S.R. (2d) 355 (Supreme Court of Nova Scotia,
Appellate Division).
Can
victim surcharges be imposed concurrently?
Victim surcharges are imposed
automatically upon conviction or discharge for each offence and there is no
discretion in the court to circumvent this automatic imposition by ordering
concurrent victim surcharges (where one payment would acquit two separate
obligations).
R. v. Fedele, 2017
ONCA 554.
Concurrent and consecutive are
concepts that apply to periods of time. There can be concurrent sentences of
incarceration or concurrent prohibitions on driving. Fines and surcharges are
not punishments which are measured in time – they are measured in amounts of
money.
Thus, the proposition that
victim surcharges can be imposed concurrently is not a logical extension of the
concept of concurrent and consecutive sentences.
Fedele, at para. 34.
Further, the wording of the
section and the legislative history of the victim surcharge regime make it
clear that Parliament intended the victim surcharge to be imposed for each and
every offence, leaving the judge with no discretion in its imposition.
Fedele, at para. 33.
Stuart O'Connell, O'Connell Law Group, leadersinlaw.ca
Comments
Post a Comment